Saturday, June 7, 2008

Problem solving

We are a work in progress it seems. A work that will never be complete until we leave this earth.

Sometimes we start out with an idea of what we want out of life. What we think we want. As we go through the living out of this life, relationships are built, crushed, ignored, restored. Events take place that change the direction of our lives, some resulting from the choices we made while others happen because of the choices others make for us, despite us, or because of us.

Like this journal entry that I don't really know where it's going, but I have an idea: I want to share yet another art project my fifth graders have been working on for a very long time it seems. For those who stayed with it, for those who had even an inkling of an idea of what they hoped their final product would look like, completion is at hand. Satisfaction is their reward for staying the course, for coming in early before school started, to finish painting their totem animal before the school year ends (on the tenth).

I wish I could have showed you the face of the boy who finished this sculpture. You'll have to settle for looking at his hands on his work. The one in the back right, not the one in the foreground. 

                                   

Here, you see two animal Totems being constructed from tape and foil. The materials were applied to a gallon milk jug. The young man I want you to follow is the one in the background, the one with the box of foil inside the milk jug.

I told them from their first day in my class that I wanted them to see the class time as a problem solving class more than an art class. Yes, we'd be making things that belonged in the category of visual arts... but as any artist or craftsman (or any field that takes specific skills and training to master) knows, along with the talent they are blessed with is a greater skill: creative thinking is not as much about making art as itis recognizing a problem, naming it, then finding a way to solve it. Or many ways.

The boy's problem at first is how to make a snake totem. He wants to represent a snake, and his first inclination is to ask me to show him how. Faced with showing each of 25 students how to make the animal they had chosen, I decide to avoid my problem (one of me, 25 of them, about 25 minutes to work) right away.

After demonstrating some technical tips about using tape and how to shape foil, I tell them they are on their own. I want them to answer their own question..."How do I do this?" which usually comes out sounding like "I don't know how to do this." or "I don't get it."

As you can see, he eventually solves his problem of making the snake.

His next problem is "My milk jug keeps falling over. It's hard to work with like that. How can I keep it from falling over?"

"Why does it keep falling over?" I ask him.

"Umm... because the snake head is heavy. It makes the jug lopsided. But I can't help that," he adds.

"So if it's heavy on one side, what can you do to keep it from falling over on that side?"

His eyebrows wrinkle. "Huh?"

I demonstrate how it falls over. His hand shoots out to right it.

"Why did you put your hand there?" I ask him.

"To keep it from falling over, but I can't work with it if I have to keep holding it with one hand like that."

"That's right, so what can you do to keep it from falling over?"

The light comes on in his head... he picks up his box of foil and drops it inside the jug. The jug remains upright. If you'll look in that first picture, you'll see the foil box inside the milk jug. A little problem solved all by his own thinking.

Afterhe paints the snake totem (a process that took about two sessions), I suggest that we spray the thing with fixative to protect the tempera paint exterior. He follows me outside, and I explain the dangers of using spray fixative. He stands some distance away while I spray. Then we walk back inside. As we pass some kindergarteners in the hall, one of them asks, "What is that?"

"What does it look like to you?" I ask him.

He smiles. Two other kinders join in, curious and impressed by this purple and green creature with the scary fangs.

                           

"I think it's a dragon," the one child says.

"I think it's  snake," another chimes in.

"That's cool!" says another.

The fifth grader is pleased with their remarks, but it is time for him to get back to class. He leaves his snake/dragon behind and returns to his homeroom.

I slide his snake on top of the other totem animals for the final picture below. He hasn't seen it this way yet... when he comes back Monday he'll see it for the first time.

                                                                                 

The purpose of the project was to learn to use the materials to make a sculpture while learning about Native American Indians. They learned the purpose of the totems, where they were found, and learned what the different animals symbolized. I'd found a list of animal symbols on the internet, made copies of a  modified list, and let them pick the animal which had qualities or characteristics they wanted for themselves, or saw in themselves.

The snake represents "impulsive, shrewdness, rebirth, transformation, initiation, and wisdom".

Yeah, I agree with that kindergartener... that's pretty cool!

 

Thanks, Marie, for the idea! The kids loved it. It just took a little longer than I'd thought it would. Next year, we'll start earlier, and I'll make sure they bring in only 3M or Scotch Brand masking tape. The lower priced brands did not stick well at all.

 

 

22 comments:

Anonymous said...

What talented 5th graders you have! I loved seeing the different pictures you showed. The finished totem looks wonderful! They all should be proud of all that they learned through this project.

I loved the parable that you used as we are "a work in progress." It seemed to fit right in with your teaching technique, which I loved. I also liked how you let the children think of problem solving and ideas for their selves, as it's easy to just give them the answers they want.

I know they will remember all that you have taught them, and will continue to apply it to other things in their lives, even when they are grown. You have taught them much and they will leave being a better person Ü.

HUGS~Donna
http://journals.aol.com/ladymagnolia1963/ladymagnolias-daily-blog/

Anonymous said...

Native Americans often told stories to provide lessons and problem solving questions. The teacher gives the story (lesson) and the students learn what lessons are being taught from that story. I love the way you encouraged each child to look within themselves to see what animal appealed to them by the descriptive nature. The final result was pretty awesome (so are the kids, who had a great teacher). (Hugs) Indigo

Anonymous said...

What a wonderful exercise in problem solving, you do amazing things with your art class. The totem is quite imposing. I know that the students will be delighted when they see the put together production. I am still so disappointed to have missed the opportunity to see your students' art work in person. Definitely next year.--Sheria

Anonymous said...

Bea,
It's fun to watch them learn, see the light click on and complete the challenge.  Good job.
David

Anonymous said...

EXCELLENT "thinking" questions!!! I LOVE this project! I may borrow your idea in my new classroom next year. It would be "cool" to have a totem pole holding up the center of my "new" portable. HA!
hugs, sher

Anonymous said...

Critical thinking is something I have tried to especially incorporate in Eler Beth's lessons this past year, because I realized that she wasn't using those skills in her school lessons.  Working on a project on her own, building something with her Dad, helping me plan my flower garden, yes, she was using critical thinking without realizing it, but not so much in math and reading and so on.  I enjoyed reading this and appreciate how you turned the student's questions back on himself so he'd learn to think for himself.  It's so easy as a parent to just tell a kid how to do something or to take it over and do it ourselves, instead of insisting that the child think for himself.  I've said it before, and I'll say it again -- you're a wonderful instructor!
Lori

Anonymous said...

Wonderful totems Bea!  I love that you allow and encourage your students to think for themselves and problem solve!  You truly are a gem!  Ohh, I would so love to teach art!  You really are blessed!
Marie
http://ayearatoakcottage.blogspot.com/

Anonymous said...

Asy ou might have seen I have a very very heavy heart today and I am not replying to journals but to try to keep other things away from my mind I am browsing...and needless to say I find I just have to reply to yours and thank you for being such a wonderful teacher what wonderful memories you are making for t hese children  much Love Sybil x

Anonymous said...

I've had a few teachers who've taken the time you do, & have also shown the pure delight they feel when we "got it" or when we felt proud of ourselves.  Each time you give a child a gift like that from the heart, it carries with them their whole life. ~Mary

Anonymous said...

A great totem pole Bea, I can just imagine his face, all their faces, when they see it.
Another excellent piece of teaching, well done.

B. x

Anonymous said...

What a great project! It must be so gratifying to see their faces when the "light bulb" goes on!

Beth

Anonymous said...

What a fun and educating project.  I think even a bunch of grownups sitting around would like to make that!  I still love to play and learn something every day.  That little guy learned some life lessons that day about problem solving.

Great job!


Nelishia
http://journals.aol.com/nelishianatl/Prayingandbelieving/

Anonymous said...

Dear Bea,
What a wonderful project! thank you so much for sharing!
I didn't know that ABC was incorrect and that the first dogs cloned were in 2005. Did they survive?
Bea you are a great educator!
so creative!
love,natalie

Anonymous said...

    Now that was cool. And to your 5th grader, great work! And great work to you, Bea. As important as art is to one's all around development, it is more important that the students become self sufficient.
    A few years back I was a Cub Scout leader. We celebrated Alaska on Pack night. One den made totem poles out of coffee cans. Those were cool, but not as colorful as yours are. My den made paper mache animals specific to Alaska using milk jugs as a base. We had a walrus, a seal and a whale. There were others, but it's been a few years and kind of hard to remember them all. It took us nearly 3 weeks to layer the jugs and paint them. They were so cool and the boys were so proud of them. On Pack Night, we showed off the art work as another den entertained us with a reading of The Night I creamated Sam McGrew. Thank you for a very pleasant memory.
Jude
http://journals.aol.com/jmorancoyle/MyWay

Anonymous said...

I've always enjoyed visiting the Totem poles that we have in Vancouver - always a sense of mystery and awe. Looks like your fifth graders had an amazing time with their project. Kudos to you!
Always, Rose~*

Anonymous said...

How very interesting, and what a great job those kids did!!  

Hugs
jackie

Anonymous said...

ABSOLUTELY FABULOUS TOTEM POLE!!!
YOU ARE ONE COOL TEACHER!
LYN

Anonymous said...

The finished work is really fun to look at!!   A good experience for them all.  -   Barbara

Anonymous said...

How wonderful and you are so good with them............ hugs, Sherry

Anonymous said...

I wish you could clone yourself and come on up to the Philadelphia, PA region. We sure could use dedicated teachers like you!!  -Karen

Anonymous said...

How wonderful is that totem pole!!
Just brillant!
Linda :)

Anonymous said...

That totem pole is so neat.  Yes, that boy will be even more interested I think when he comes back and sees that.  I send so many packages off I have had adventures with tape but not like yours, oh lady, not like yours.  I do so admire the creative in you.  Gerry